Is Gary, Indiana Really as Dangerous as People Say?

Latest Posts


Gary, Indiana - Rise and Fall
Share Post :

Gary, Indiana – the mere mention of it conjures up images of crime-ridden streets, abandoned buildings, and a city in decline. But is Gary really as dangerous as people say? Let’s take a look.

The Rise and Fall of Gary

Rise of Gary, Indiana

Gary was once a bustling industrial hub, known for its booming steel mills. The city was even nicknamed “The Magic City” due to its rapid growth and industrial prowess.

It’s also the birthplace of the legendary Jackson 5. In the mid-1990s, though, Gary was infamous for a different reason – it held the notorious title of the murder capital of the world.

A Grim Statistic

Back in 1994-1995, Gary was ranked as the most dangerous place in the United States. According to reports from Tuko, with a population of 115,269 in 1995, the city saw over 3,000 reported crimes that year.

The most shocking statistic? There were 129 murders in 1995, giving Gary the highest number of murders per capita in the country.

The Industrial Decline

Industry in Gary, Indiana

Gary’s decline can be traced back to the fall of the manufacturing industry. As the steel industry crumbled, so did the city’s economy.

Businesses shuttered their doors, and the once-thriving cityscape turned into a landscape of urban decay. Abandoned churches, storefronts, and other buildings became the new norm.

Population and Economic Woes

Historical Population of Gary, Indiana

The population of Gary has been on a steady decline. From a peak of around 200,000 residents, the number dwindled to just 69,093 by 2020.  The economic downturn brought on by the collapse of the steel industry led to high poverty rates and an increase in crime.

According to IURC, today, Gary’s median household income stands at $31,936, with a significant portion of the population living below the poverty line.

Crime Rates – Then and Now

Crime rates in Gary have improved since the 1990s, but the city is still considered dangerous. Recent efforts to combat crime include high-technology crime centers and community programs like Gary for Life, which have begun to show positive results in reducing violence.

Despite these improvements, residents still experience high levels of fear. Many are afraid to walk the streets alone due to the risk of being robbed or shot.

What About Crime Rates in Gary in 2024?

Violent Crime Rate

  • As per Neighborhoodscout, Gary has a high violent crime rate, with recent trends showing a slight decrease in homicides due to effective community programs.
  • The chance of being a victim of violent crime is significantly higher than the national average.

Property Crime Rate

  • Property crime, including burglary, larceny, and motor vehicle theft, remains prevalent.
  • The likelihood of experiencing property crime is approximately 1 in 32.


  • There has been a noted reduction in homicides due to targeted violence prevention programs.
  • Gary has historically struggled with high homicide rates but has seen improvements in recent years.

Community Programs

The good thing is, it’s not all grim in Gary Indiana nowadays. As Thetrace reports, violence prevention initiatives have positively impacted overall crime rates in the city, as these programs were designed to address gun violence and have shown measurable success in reducing crime.

Life Expectancy and Health

Gary, Indiana - Ghetto

Gary also struggles with health issues. According to Dailymail, the city has one of the lowest life expectancies in the United States, significantly below the national average.

Economic hardships and the resulting stress contribute to this grim statistic.

Community Reflections

Many long-time residents recall a time when the city was safer and more prosperous.

The stark contrast between Gary’s past and present is evident in the memories of those who have lived through the changes. The once-thriving community now grapples with issues of gun violence and urban decay.

Efforts to Rebuild

Despite the challenges, there are ongoing efforts to revitalize Gary. Community programs, investments in infrastructure, and initiatives to attract businesses aim to breathe new life into the city. However, the road to recovery is long and fraught with obstacles.

Is Gary Still Dangerous?

So, is Gary, Indiana really as dangerous as people say? The answer is complicated. While the city has made strides in reducing crime and improving safety, it still grapples with significant challenges.

The legacy of its industrial decline, economic hardships, and high poverty rates continue to impact the community. To get a better picture, you can check out the polls on Niche, where citizen gave their answers about how safe they actually feel in this city.

A Glimmer of Hope

There is hope for Gary. Community-driven initiatives and investments in the city’s future offer a glimmer of optimism.

The spirit of the residents, their resilience, and their commitment to their city are crucial to its revival. With continued efforts and support, Gary can shed its reputation as a dangerous city and build a brighter, safer future.

Final Words

Gary, Indiana, is a city with a complex history. Once a thriving industrial hub, it fell into decline and became infamous for its crime rates.  While the city still faces significant challenges, ongoing efforts to improve safety and revitalize the community offer hope.

Gary’s story is one of resilience and determination, and with continued support, the city can overcome its troubled past and move toward a brighter future.